Skip to content
107 av. Victor Hugo, Paris 16th11 rue Lacépède, Paris 5th
Fertility

Failed IVF: what are the options if you have never been pregnant?

By Dr Olivier Kadoch, obstetrician-gynaecologistReviewed on Next review: October 20277 min read

In brief

After several failed IVF (in vitro fertilisation) cycles, the first step is to review your complete medical record with your team, or to ask for a second opinion, to look for a cause that can be corrected (uterus, tubes, endometriosis, sperm, protocol). Depending on age and ovarian reserve, the options are a new, adjusted attempt, egg or sperm donation, embryo donation, adoption, or stopping fertility treatment. There is no single right answer: the decision belongs to the couple, once fully informed.

What causes a failed IVF cycle?

A failed IVF cycle is common and does not mean you can never have a child. Even with a good-quality embryo, implantation is never guaranteed. The causes of failure fall mainly into three areas:

  • the embryo: this is the most common cause. The proportion of embryos with chromosomal abnormalities rises with the woman’s age, which explains the drop in results after 38–40;
  • the ovarian response: few eggs collected, often linked to a low ovarian reserve;
  • the uterus and pelvis: a polyp, a fibroid distorting the cavity, adhesions (synechiae), a dilated fallopian tube (hydrosalpinx) whose fluid interferes with implantation, adenomyosis or endometriosis.

Male factors and the stimulation protocol can also play a part. Often, no specific cause is found.

What are the usual steps before IVF?

Assisted reproductive technology (ART) usually moves forward in stages, depending on the cause of infertility and on age:

  1. fertility tests for both partners, which point to the right technique (see infertility tests);
  2. intrauterine insemination (IUI), often offered first for unexplained infertility or moderately abnormal sperm. The partner’s sperm or donor sperm is placed in the uterus at the time of ovulation;
  3. IVF, after failed inseminations, or straight away for blocked tubes, severely abnormal sperm, severe endometriosis or older age;
  4. ICSI, a form of IVF in which a single sperm is injected into each egg, for significantly abnormal sperm or when fertilisation failed during standard IVF.

One IVF "attempt" includes the egg collection and all the embryo transfers that come from it, fresh and then frozen. It is therefore helpful to take stock with your team after each complete attempt, rather than after each transfer, to judge the results.

It is also important to distinguish a failure to conceive (negative test) from a miscarriage after a positive test: these two situations do not mean the same thing and are not investigated in the same way.

What is recurrent implantation failure?

The European Society of Human Reproduction and Embryology (ESHRE) published guidance on recurrent implantation failure in 2023. It defines it as the situation where transfer of embryos considered viable has not led to a positive pregnancy test often enough, in a given patient, to justify further tests or treatment. It suggests a threshold: when the expected cumulative chance of implantation for the number of transfers already carried out exceeds 60% without success, further investigations are discussed.

This definition takes into account age and embryo quality: there is no "magic number" of failures that applies to everyone.

Which tests should be repeated after several failed IVF cycles?

Reviewing your file at a dedicated appointment, or asking another team for its opinion, helps make sure nothing has been missed. Depending on the situation, the following may be discussed:

AreaPossible testsWhat can be corrected
Uterine cavity3D ultrasound, saline infusion sonography, hysteroscopyPolyp larger than 10 mm, fibroid distorting the cavity, adhesions
Tubes and pelvisUltrasound, pelvic MRI, sometimes laparoscopyHydrosalpinx (treated before a new IVF cycle), endometriosis
Male factorRepeat semen analysis, andrology opinionChoice of ICSI, treatment of a male cause
General healthThyroid, blood sugar, depending on historyTreatment of an associated condition, weight, smoking
GeneticsKaryotype of both partners if indicatedGenetic counselling, preimplantation genetic testing

The stimulation protocol can also be adjusted. However, ESHRE (2023) points out that many "add-on" tests and treatments offered after failure (certain immunological tests, immune treatments, endometrial scratching, etc.) have not been shown to increase live births and should not be prescribed routinely.

What options are there after failed IVF?

A new, adjusted attempt

When age and ovarian reserve allow, and a way to improve things has been identified, a new IVF cycle may be offered. Transferring the remaining frozen embryos is part of the same attempt and does not require a new stimulation (see the stages of IVF).

Egg or sperm donation

When egg quality or number is the problem, egg donation clearly changes the outlook, because the chances then depend mainly on the donor’s age. Sperm donation may be offered for a severe male cause. In France, donation is anonymous and unpaid; since the 2021 bioethics law, people born from a donation can, once they turn 18, access the donor’s identity if they wish. Waiting times can be long. Dr Kadoch can refer you to an appropriate assisted reproduction centre.

Embryo donation

Couples who have completed their family can donate their frozen embryos to a couple or an unmarried woman. In France, consent to receive an embryo is first given before a notary.

Adoption

In France, adoption first requires an approval (agrément) issued by the département council, after a social and psychological assessment. Adoption may concern a child born in France who is a ward of the State, or a child born abroad; since the law of 21 February 2022, international adoption must go through an authorised adoption agency (OAA) or the French Adoption Agency (AFA); independent adoptions are no longer possible. The process is long and the number of children available for adoption is limited.

A natural pregnancy

If no definitive cause has been found (open tubes, ovulation present, sperm present), a natural pregnancy remains possible, even after failed IVF. This chance is often low and should be assessed honestly with your doctor, according to age.

When and how do you decide to stop fertility treatment?

Deciding to stop is one of the hardest steps of the journey. It rests on several factors, to be discussed together:

  • the woman’s age, the main factor in the outlook, and the age limits for cover by the Assurance maladie (French national health insurance);
  • the response to stimulation and the quality of the embryos obtained;
  • the number of attempts already made and their outcome;
  • how the couple is coping: fatigue, psychological distress, impact on work, social and intimate life.

Stopping is not a personal failure. Some couples choose another path (donation, adoption), others build a life without children. A break of a few months can also help to step back before deciding.

Where can I find support after failed IVF?

Repeated failures can lead to anxiety, sadness, sometimes depression, and can put strain on the relationship. Do not hesitate to ask for psychological support, offered in most fertility centres. Patient associations also let you talk with couples going through the same situation.

If you are in severe distress or having dark thoughts, in France you can call 3114, the national suicide prevention line, free, 24/7.

Would you like a medical opinion?Appointments in Paris 16th or 5th, or by video consultation.

Book an appointment

Frequently asked questions

How many IVF cycles are covered in France?

In France, the Assurance maladie (national health insurance) covers a limited number of IVF attempts, subject to the woman's age. Transfers of frozen embryos from the same egg collection count as part of the same attempt; your centre will explain your own situation.

Are immunological tests useful after several failed IVF cycles?

ESHRE guidelines do not recommend them routinely, because immune treatments have not been shown to increase live births. They may be discussed with your team in specific situations.

Does changing fertility clinic improve the chances?

Not necessarily, but a second opinion may spot something that has not been explored or suggest a different protocol. It is a legitimate and common step.

Can endometriosis explain failed IVF?

It can reduce ovarian reserve and, depending on its form, interfere with implantation. Its treatment, sometimes surgical, is discussed case by case before a new attempt.

Can I have egg donation abroad?

Some couples do, under legal rules and conditions that differ from those in France. It is advisable to talk to your gynaecologist before taking any steps, for the medical follow-up of the pregnancy and for cover.

References

  • Sonigo C, et al. Prise en charge du couple infertile en première intention. Recommandations pour la pratique clinique du CNGOF 2022 [First-line management of infertile couples. CNGOF clinical practice guidelines 2022]. Gynecol Obstet Fertil Senol, 2024. doi:10.1016/j.gofs.2024.01.014 — PMID 38311310
  • ESHRE Working Group on Recurrent Implantation Failure. ESHRE good practice recommendations on recurrent implantation failure. Hum Reprod Open, 2023. doi:10.1093/hropen/hoad023 — PMID 37332387
  • ESHRE Add-ons working group. Good practice recommendations on add-ons in reproductive medicine. Hum Reprod, 2023. doi:10.1093/humrep/dead184 — PMID 37747409

Dr Olivier KadochObstetrician-gynaecologist and gynaecological surgeon in Paris, seeing patients in Paris 16th and at the Centre de la Femme Paris 5. Former chef de clinique-assistant (senior registrar) at the Paris public hospitals (AP-HP); individually accredited by the French National Authority for Health (HAS). RPPS 10003957809. Background and practice locations

A question about your situation?Appointments at the practice or by video consultation, usually within one week to 10 days.

Book an appointment

General information article: it does not replace a medical consultation. In an emergency, call 15 or 112 in France, or your local emergency number.